I think Alan Tudyk did this scene the best. James Mardsen failed big time. When Alan does it you can tell its Alan and we get to see a lot of him. When James did it you had to ask yourself was that him or a body double and the camera seemed to have ADD or something. Why did James even bother if he was not going to show as much as Alan did, he should have decline the role for someone who was willing to show what Alan showed.